Sure!
I just took a look at your list and I'll say something about your to watch list first; ChäoS;HEAd is pretty bad. I guess you added it to your list after watching Steins;Gate? (same universe) They are both based on visual novels but ChäoS;HEAd was really rushed in comparison to Steins;Gate.
As for some actual recommendations:
Code Geass
Durarara!
Shiki
One Outs
Darker than Black
Phantom - Requiem for the Phantom
Mahou Shoujo Madoka Magica
Your higher ranked anime were all kind of "dark" which is the reason for the recommendations. I think I had more but I accidentally pressed back and had to rewrite the post, lol
Anyway, I'm not too sure about what genres you like. I had a few comedy, slice of life, ecchi, romance and random fantasy action magic anime but didn't recommend.
Another option is to sort by score and check my list for more names.
I still haven't seen the seasons 5-7 again like I wanted to.
The funny thing is, in the past I brought some of the epvp members to the Doctor and they liked it very much. More Whovians. Muhaaa ^^
Hallo, ich habe gestern von dir eine Verwarnung erhalten. Der Grund lautet: Spam/Double Post. Nun ist meine Frage warum? Ich habe doch nur in meinem Thema PUSH geschrieben, weil ich es mal pushen wollte. Und ich habe es doch nicht am gleichen Tag gemacht?