Its like you didnt read what he said, he said he doesnt consider a list ip addresses valid proof, and i agree, anyone can generate a list of ips, anyone can get them off their own forum, anyone can get them from their own users.
Not hard.
And as i explained to you at the time, i deleted your post because a list of ip addresses, if they were real (collected from a forum or otherwise), opens many people up to all sorts of attacks, not something we can allow here at epvpers, even moderators here cant get hold of peoples ip addresses because its considered to be too dangerous.