I have played this server for 3 weeks and have quit now, so I will only mention the bad stuff (I quit after all)
1. The auto-hunt penalty harms new players over old players.
Because you get 20% gold drops with auto-hunt you will end up spending all or 80% of the gold u earn on potions, meanwhile old players get to auto-hunt because they get SoX drops, the current penalty on auto-hunt is 20% gold 40% drops. It should be the opposite in my opinion
2. No balance, claims to have balanced classes, but all parties are wizards and bard and sometimes nuker, good luck getting into any party if u play STR or god forbid Chinese. I'm not going to talk too much because I know there's a balance patch in the works
3. Claims to be Play2Win, but is the exact opposite.
Currently, there's no way to get a pet clock or extension for free, So there will always be a constant need for silk, There are 4 ways to gain free silk at the moment (all of which give 25 non-tradable silk)
3/4 are End game only, so you need to sink months into the game before u can earn any silk, and the last one is a unique that spawns like twice a day, so good luck getting silk.
Developers removed silk scrolls from the game, but that does nothing at all. You are allowed to buy silk from other players directly from their discord, and on top of that silk bought with real life currency is tradable, so the entirety of Hotan is filled with stalls selling premium and reverse scroll etc.
If developers wanted this server to truly be Play2Win, silk earned through in-game activities would be tradable and silk bought with IRL money would be untradable
I'm not criticizing because I have malicious intent, I wish the developers would fix all the issues listed above. There's a lot of good stuff about the game, but the bad stuff cloud all the good stuff.