[IcT] Conquer Fluride

06/17/2005 18:47 Lateralus#16
I didn't leech and post anything on here on MSX...I just need to know for sure that they are scamming..and if they are..I'm leaving..I'm waiting for LiX to message me back! This website really better not be a scam. If it is..sorry! :ops:
06/17/2005 19:23 XtremeX-CO#17
This website is not a scam......
06/17/2005 19:23 XtremeX-CO#18
EDIT:opps double post sorry.
06/18/2005 11:44 Lowfyr#19
wishafur, msx sells work from many cs hacking groups (e.g. ict, game-deception) wich you can get free, that is scamming imo
06/18/2005 13:39 Eldix#20
thanks for the taoist trainer =p
06/18/2005 18:17 w0rf#21
Lowfyr. Game-Deception lives under the GPL. Honestly, if you ever visit their Code section on their forum, you would know that, if of course you don't already.

GPL states, that a person can take anything released under the GPL, and sell it, modify it, release it, and do anything they want with it, since the original author is basically giving it out.

Maybe you have heard of PearPC? It's a Mac OS X Emulator for the PC. Well, it's open source and under the GPL. A company named like, Maui-StreamX or something took their code (which was proven they stole it) and compiled it all with a new GUI and started selling it as, "CherryOS." Maybe you've heard of that? It's always coming up in the news on Slashdot.

PearPC developers can't sue them or anything, can only cry about it and talk shit on CherryOS, because they released their code under the GPL. It's basically what goes on with Counter-Strike cheats.

Also, you have to realize, that, MSX doesn't sell cheats specifically. MSX sells VIP accounts on his website, which leads to private forum access, more community stuff, access to cheats, etc. He isn't selling each cheat.

Although, he is selling a cheat named XeoN or something, because the author spoke to MSX and they worked out a deal, so he would sell that cheat directly and they would split the money.
06/18/2005 18:46 Eldix#22
Actually, federal law states that selling access to a product is considered selling the product itself. You are charging people for the privaledge of using that product.
06/18/2005 19:05 w0rf#23
If you look at it that way, sure you might think it's a scam, and it might be or not. But, I'm not saying this is a state of federal law or anything. I'm just stating what the GPL allows people to do with GPL-Licensed code.

So, if you look at it that way, Eldix, MSX can still do this legally. All the hacks for Counter-Strike, etc. that he has on his site are either under GPL'd or ripped from GPL'd code (OGC tweaks, etc.) So he can technically sell them all he wants, whether it's indirectly selling them, or "directly" selling them as you might be implying.
06/18/2005 19:16 Eldix#24
I never said that what MSX is doing is illegal, I was just correcting you when you said he's not actually selling it. According to the law, he is selling it.
06/18/2005 20:16 w0rf#25
Could you show me a link to that law?
06/18/2005 20:21 Eldix#26
Dude, I'm not about to look through all the laws and find it for you. Just trust me, my father was fined and put on probation because he decided that having a hooker in a hotel room and renting out the room wasn't considered prostitution. He didn't sell the hooker, he sold the room, and access to the hooker.
06/18/2005 21:34 cheapbastard#27
aren't you going way offtopic...

LiX, is there perhaps a webpage or something where we could check the progress of this hack (or perhaps you could post progress reports here)?
06/18/2005 21:35 Eldix#28
Yes, we did get way off topic. Anyone know a speed hack that works?
06/18/2005 21:54 LiX#29
Sure I will setup a progress report page now on IcT. :)
06/18/2005 22:08 Eldix#30
sweet