Hi again, someone made a comment of balance in this thread and i wanted to point out somethings and suggest somethings about AL and the economy that goes with it/feeds its success.
The Price of Marvel Scrolls and its importance:
1. Marvel scrolls should be at least 4 euro per scroll.
Reason being is that the value of them will maintain a way to buy certain high level things in one trade (ex. gold ticket = 12 scrolls + gold or whatever). If they were cheap like 50 cents (justac) you cannot get anything special in one trade because the value of the scroll is basically not worth enough for the item wanted. This keeps the game more off of paypal and into the server.
2. Free scroll in buddy system
The game needs this, this gives a way for people who have no choice but to play for free or who just choose to play for free a way to get anything with hard work/continued play. Also a huge point to this is it attracts new people, through joining a friend on the server your pretty much assured a way into the economy for free just for leveling up to 70 (dont remember the requirement). Of course you will have people who do this over and over as way to gain high end stuff like gold and premium tickets, but that is the free option and it takes much time.
3. Understanding how marvel scroll is good to AL
The marvel scroll is good to archlord not only for the ability to trade bound items or the ability to purchase other items with scrolls, but it is also good because it is the one and only item in the CC shop that is not power based and hence does not alter game balancing! (yaaaah for marvel scroll the first balanced item in AL lol). Meaning that trading these impact no hard value of the game in terms of power. Example being a person is buying 20 euro of cc in game and spending 16 of that on scrolls (4 sc), a item that does not directly add power through a source of buying but is a way to get things or trade things you or someone DROPPED in game not BOUGHT.
4. Price of other cc in relation to marvel scroll price
The price of other things in the shop should be cheaper because of the need of price increase to marvel scrolls value. If you had to put the cc shop into 4 categories i think it would be:
A. CC potions: all time based potions like hp pot and combi etc.
B. Boosters: items such as Toa, Toh, Suits, Pets.
C. Utilities: passport scrolls, sog, destiny, release, return, soe etc.
D. Broken (lol): Cloaks, ring chest, tickets, race box, premium box etc
Things in section A should be very cheap, or even free with the exception of combi, but the combi should be cheaper, about 50 cents per stack is fair right? Making a scroll worth 8 combi stack, this way its not free but its not like unable to afford either, making things very F2P and less P2W. Combi is a big need to some people at all times and on a private server why not let that be a thing?
Things in section B should be partially based off of the xp/drop percentage you plan to use for start of server. If you plan to have closer to 150% xp rate these things should be cheaper even down to 10 and 20 cent per 1 day. If you plan to be up towards 500% xp rate they should be more expensive up to like 1 dollar and 2 dollars per 1 day. If you plan to add "OP" suits then id put it in the D section (lol)
Things in section C are all things that teleport or edits or allows you to chat server wide, this section would vary in price of course but main thing here is to have soe reasonable but not so cheap to create spam(3 bucks per 100?). All the other items that would be described a utility cant really be exploited or add any type of power so i think they shouldn't be more than a dollar but not less than 50 cents.
Things in section D are things where it should be the most expensive with only a few exceptions. The exceptions should be with price of things that justac has like ring spirit/cloaks, you should keep the same price or make it a little cheaper, i know the goal is to create a slower paced server but those 2 things you cant make it more than they have it in my opinion.
THE PROBLEM: The stuff you have and justac dont have like race boxes, premium boxes, fortune gates, Janus/sezarens, and inventory extension you have to be very careful of the price! If you make the boxes too cheap it can effect the pace of the server, flooding it early with scions and ashtals and refined uniques, not to mention gold ticket request lol which admin have to do weekly.
Thing is if you make it too expensive people will complain that your server is fully P2W and webzen part 2. This is because some people will spend no matter how much the boxes are if the reward of opening the box is as big as gold tickets ashtals n scions etc.
The SOLUTION: A. Either let the boxes be expensive like webzen + have the items dropable for free in the world by some hard method of refining or something dropping from some boss. Or B. take that content out of the server until later months when new stuff is needed and economy is established to better know where prices should be on this.
done :P